Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
skip to main |
skip to sidebar
Fight Club Links
CALENDARS & ASSIGNMENTS
Frankenstein Links
Hamlet Links
Madness Links
The Stranger
McMurphy & the Chief
Nurse Ratched
Blog Archive
-
►
2009
(1)
- ► 01/04 - 01/11 (1)
-
▼
2008
(14)
- ► 11/16 - 11/23 (1)
- ► 11/09 - 11/16 (2)
- ► 10/26 - 11/02 (4)
- ► 09/21 - 09/28 (1)
- ► 09/14 - 09/21 (2)
- ► 09/07 - 09/14 (2)
23 comments:
The book and movie have distinct differences that set them apart from each other. In the movie, Elizabeth is adopted into the Frankenstein family, however in the book, Caroline discovers Elizabeth in Italy. Here, Caroline notices Elizabeth’s beautiful blonde hair that separates her from the other Italian girls. Elizabeth is the daughter of a Milanese noblemen and German woman. Although Elizabeth is adopted differently in the movie and book, she and Victor still fall in love with each other in the end. When Caroline is on her deathbed, she tells Victor and Elizabeth how she wishes that they get married someday. In the movie, Caroline dies giving birth to a newborn, however, in the book she dies from scarlet fever. Caroline contracts the disease when she is taking care of Elizabeth. Furthermore, through Victor’s life, he is close with Elizabeth and another boy, Henry Clerval. In the movie, Victor meets Henry at the university at Ingolstadt, however, in the book they are friends right from the beginning. Although they remain friends throughout Victor’s journey in the book and movie, the book explains that their friendship began during Victor’s childhood.
While the book and movie resemble each other, there are a few major differences. First, when Elizabeth joins the family, in the book, the Frankenstein family had been traveling. Whenever they stopped somewhere, they would help poor people they met. One particular time, they met a family who had a girl living with them, who had been born noble but had since lost her parents. Caroline was attracted to her beauty and they adopted her. In the movie, Elizabeth is brought to the family's home because she is orphaned. Another major difference, is that in the movie, Victor's father is a doctor and serves as part of his inspiration for his studies and is the doctor to his mother when she dies. In the book, Victor's father is described as being not scientific, and therefore unable to help him with his interest in the subject. The final major difference is the way in which Caroline Frankenstein dies. In the book, she dies from scarlet fever after contracting the disease from Elizabeth. Even though she had been advised to stay away from Elizabeth, she could not resist attending to her. In the movie, she dies giving birth to Victor's little brother. In reality, she lived through the childbirth.
The book varies greatly from the movie. In the book, the story is narrated by R. Walton. He writes three letters at the beginning, introducing the story of Frankenstein. In the movie, the story is a biography of Frankenstein's life, not a narrative. Also, in the book, Caroline gets scarlet fever from Elizabeth and dies. In the movie, she dies in childbirth. Finally, Henry, in the novel, is a good friend of Frankenstein's from home. In the movie, Henry appears only when he arrives at college.
Even though the movie has done a good job of getting the main idea across thus far, there are a few small differences between the movie and the book. One of the first differences is the movie doesn't illustrate Walton's letters to his sister, it just starts of with Walton and his crew meeting Frankenstein, which is also different in the book. In the movie, Frankenstein comes across Walton and his crew in good health and on land, but in the book, Frankenstein is floating by on a piece of ice and very weak. Also, in the movie, Frankenstein's father brings home Elizabeth to join the family. In the book, Frankenstein's mother and father find her in Italy, poor and without a family, and decide to adopt her. Another difference is in the movie Frankenstein's mother, Caroline, dies during childbirth, but in the book she dies of scarlet fever that she got from Elizabeth.
The book and the movie of Frankenstein have a few differences between them. Firstly, the movie is a biography of Frankenstein's that is not narrated by him, but the book is "written" by R. Walton's point of view. Secondly, the way Caroline dies is different in the book and movie. In the book, Caroline dies from scarlet fever but in the movie she dies giving birth. One other difference is the way that Elizabeth is brought into the Frankenstein family. In the movie, she is brought to the house because she is an orphan in need of a family. However, in the book, Alphonse and Caroline discover her when they're traveling around the world. They encountered the family that she was living with and Caroline instantly fell in love with her so they decided to adopt her.
Even though the movie is meant to be an imitation of the book, there are a number of significant differences between these two types of presentation. Starting with the introduction of Elizabeth into the story. In the novel, the Frankensteins first meet Elizabeth while they were traveling in Italy. But in the movie, Elizabeth was brought to the Frankensteins simply as an orphan. The detailed story of Elizabeth's origin is significant because it resembles the way Alphonse met Caroline. Another distinction between the book and the movie is the way how Caroline died. In the movie, she died giving birth to William, Victor's younger brother, but in the novel, she dies from scarlet fever. Caroline dying from giving birth to William increases the significance of William’s death because it means that the monster has taken a life that Victor’s mother sacrificed herself giving birth to. The third significant variation between the book and the movie is Alphonse's occupation. In the book, Alphonse was a well respected businessman, but in the movie he was a doctor. I believe that Alphonse being a doctor really broadens the reason why Victor has so much interest in science since he was a child.
There are some major differences in the book and movie. One bieng that Caroline dies in childbirth in the movie and in the book she dies of scarlet fever which she attained from Elizabeth. Elizabeth is introduced to the family as an orphan in the movie and in the book she is discovered in Italy. Although major differences occur with Caroline and Elizabeth; the letters in the book are told as a narrative from the captain while in the movie it is not a narrative.
for me a major diffrence that had not already been discused was the begining scene. In the book there are four letters which foreshadow future drama in the book. in the movie there was an opening scene where we are presented with a young captian who desires to reach the north pole. although most of the plot is similar in the movie it is alot more dramatic. in the movie there is a great sence of fear that is presented. one example is the dog scene where the moster kills about eight dogs and everyone is sacred.
There are few differences between the movie and the book. First of all, the movie does not show how Elizabeth becomes adopted. In the book, Caroline finds her when she travels. Also, the movie reflects that the death of Caroline, Victor's mother, happens because of the birth of William. However, Caroline dies because of scarlet fever in the book. Lastly, the movie shows that Victor meets his friend,Henry Clerval, when he goes to school. But the book describes Henry as Victor's friend since they are young. Although the book and the movie show the differences of some points, both of them reflects the inner mind of Victor Frankenstein and the morality of reviving human's life.
Both the book and the movie have differences that even though are minor, change parts of the story. The three major differences are the death of Victor's mother, the adoption of Elizabeth and the friendship of Victor and Henry Clerval. In the movie Victor's mom, Caroline, dies from giving birth to his brother, William, while in the book she dies by contracting the scarlet fever from Elizabeth. The adoption of Elizabeth in the movie is random when a man brings her in and in the book is when Caroline is traveling and she stands out. Caroline travels to Italy and Elizabeth stands out from the other girls and Caroline decides to adopt her. The friendship of Henry and Victor in the movie starts when they meet at Ingolstadt, their school, while in the book they have known each other for a while and they grew up together.
The movie follows the general plot of Frankenstein, but it differs in some areas. First off, in the book Caroline dies of scarlet fever, in the movie she dies during childbirth. In the movie, Elizabeth is an orphaned child who they adopt. In the book Caroline notices Elizabeth while in Milan, Italy because of her blonde hair; she looked different than the other girls and so she adopted her. Lastly, in the book Henry and Victor are childhood friends, in the movie they don’t meet until they attend university at Ingolstadt.
The book and the the movie Frankenstein have a few important differences between them. For one, Caroline dies from scarlet fever in the book rather than during childbirth in the movie. Another difference is the adopting of Elizabeth. In the movie she just shows up at the house but in the book Victor's mom finds her in Italy and adopts her. A third difference surrounds Victor's best friend, Henry Clerval. In the movie he doesn't have a friend from home but rather from school. In the book Henry is his friend from home and does not go to school with Victor. The movie is a good representation of the book but there are a few differences between each.
The book and the movie of Frankenstein, are fairly different from each other. In the movie, Elizabeth is brought to the house because she is an orphan in need of a family. In the book however, Alphonse and Caroline discover her in Italy, when they're traveling around the world. They encountered the family that she was living with and Caroline instantly fell in love with her since she had a beuty that stood out from the other kids. Secondly, is Victor's mother's death. In the movie, Caroline dies from giving birth to Victor's little brother. Meanwhile in the book, she survives when giving birth, and dies from scarlet fever that she obtained from taking care of Elizabeth. Lastly, Alphonse's carrer apppear to be different in the book than in the movie. In the movie, he serves as Victor's role model in terms of scientific traits. Mean while in the book, he has nothing to do with science, and can't share the same ambition for it with Victor. Most movies however, are never as detailed as the books. They just represent a skim through of the novel along with the producer's vision of how he/she wants the public to react.
There are a couple significant aspects that show the difference of the movie to the book. For instance, Caroline’s death in the movie was cause by birth but in the book it was due to her catching scarlet fever. Also, Elizabeth’s presence in the Frankenstein family is another difference. The movie just shows her coming through the doors and being adopted while in the book, Caroline discovers her. As Caroline was in Italy she noticed her and decided to adopt her and bring her home. Henry Clerval is Victor’s best friend as he was growing up in the book. In the movie however the y show Henry meeting Victor at school in Ingolstadt, they do not show any evidence that they were friends before hand in the movie. As the book and the movie show the same story line, it is evident that they o show some differences.
The book and the movie have some big differences. In the movie Carolines dies giving birth and in the book she dies from scarlet fever. Another difference is in the movie Frankenstein meets Henry at University and in the book he meets him right from the beggining. The last difference is in the book Elizabteh was found in Italy by Caroline and in the movie she is just introduced to the family. The father just walks her in and tells Victor that this is his new sister.
The book Frankenstein and the movie have a few different variations from each other. First of all the novel begins with the reading of letters that the sailor is sending home to his sister. This is overlooked in the movie. Caroline dies in different ways in the movie and the novel. In the novel she dies from scarlet fever, while in the movie she dies in childbirth. Also the novel tells us that Caroline was found in Italy, a blonde among dark haired Italians. While in the movie she is adopted.
there are a couple differences, most noticably is the way the book is told through the captain and in the movie it is more just following victor and stuff. secondly, victors mom, Caroline, dies during childbirth in the movie, and in the book she dies of illness. Also, his sister is adopted in the movie, and in the book she is found in Italy and is brought home by victors parents because they immediatly fall in love with her innocence and want her to have a better life than the one she seems to be leading at that point in time.
well it is clear that there are some major differences between the book and the movie of Frankenstein by Mary Shelley. one big difference is the way that caroline dies. in the movie she dies by giving birth to victor's little brother but in the book she dies from the dreaded scarlet fever. another big difference is how elizabeth is acquired by the Frankenstein family. in the book victor's mother finds elizabeth in italy and it is done differently in the movie. Also, elizabeth has beautiful blonde hair that caroline notices. the final difference for me comes with the description of victor's father. in the book he is described as not being into science like victor while in the movie it seems that he was a big part of the reason why victor became interested in the subject. thats all for now
The book and the movie have the same general concepts, but some of the details are different. in the movie Elizabeth if adopted, however in the book, caroline finds her in italy. in the book caroline dies from the scarlet fever and in the book she dies from giving birth. a third difference is victor's affiliation with henry. in the book, victor grew up with henry and in the movie he meets him in ingolstadt. the book and the movie are somewhat similar, except for some smaller minor details.
The book and the film of Frankenstein have a few very major differences. For instance, in the film, Elizabeth is adopted into the Frankenstein family because both her parents perished. In the book, however, Victor Frankenstein's mother, Caroline, finds Elizabeth in Italy and adopts her because she thought Elizabeth was different due to her blond hair. Another example is the way Caroline dies is both the movie and the book. In the movie, Caroline dies in childbirth while giving birth to Victor's brother, William. Although in the book, she dies of scarlet fever. The book and movie are both the same in that in her will, she wishes that Elizabeth and Victor marry, which they end up doing. Also, the relationship between Victor and his friend, Henry Clerval. In the Frankenstein film, Victor met Henry at the university they both attended at Ingolstadt. In the story, they are friends from the beginning in Geneva and Henry visits Victor at the university. In conclusion, the three main differences between the book and the film thus far are the way Elizabeth was adopted into the family, the way Victor's mother dies, and the relationship between Henry and Victor.
In the book caroline dies from scarlet fever but in the movie she dies while giving birth to william. The movie also shows the Frankenstein family adopting Elizabeth from an Italian orphanage but the book actually states that she was a little girl who lost both of her parents, and was living with a new caring family. This is where they adopted her from. It also states that they noticed her blonde hair in a sea of dark hair. Victor did not meet his friend Henry when he goes to study in England. He and Henry have been friends since they were little boys. Also I highly doubt that in the book Frankenstein rips the heart out of Elizabeth. The movie portrays it as a violent act but I do not think it is supposed to be.
There are many differences between the movie we watched and the book we read. First, Elizabeth is actually found by Caroline in Italy rather than being adopted by the family. Second,at the beginning of the book are the letters Walton sent to his sister, but in the movie instead, was the scene that he travels towards the north pole and encounters a storm.
The movie is derived from the book, and it is obvious that the director has made several changes to the original script.
Post a Comment